Demonstrating strategic value to secure leadership buy-in
As an employer brand practitioner, have you ever wondered how to gain more buy-in, support, and investment from senior leaders for your employer brand strategy? If so, you’re not alone.
A large organisation, virtually present in every country across the globe, a manufacturer of products that most of us have used at some point, but that most of us will not recognise by name. The opportunity to increase employer brand awareness and attract the right talent was clear. So much so that the newly created employer brand team successfully secured a large investment to develop the organisation’s first-ever Employee Value Proposition (EVP). Twelve months later, the employer brand team conducted an internal-first launch of a concept they thought captured the essence of what it is like to work for the organisation and received great feedback from leaders and employees. Following the internal validation of the new EVP, it was time to present the business case for the global external launch, which of course came with another investment ask. But to the team’s surprise, the response was:
Needless to say, this wasn’t the response they anticipated. Yet, upon reflection, it aligned with the organisation’s early stage on the employer brand maturity curve. Leaders could not visualise the potential impact of actively and purposefully managing the employer brand on business success.
I couldn’t help but wonder: If people are the one competitive advantage that cannot be fully replicated by competitors, how can senior leaders overlook the value of promoting the company’s employer brand to attract and retain the right talent – and, in turn, achieve business goals?
A well-aligned employer brand strategy can be a powerful catalyst for business success. However, in my experience and humble opinion, some of us, employer brand practitioners, are failing to communicate the opportunities and potential impact of employer branding in a language senior leaders can relate to, in a way that clearly shows how their investment and support will contribute to advancing those elements of the business they care about the most, and therefore, why building a strong employer brand should feature in the list of top investment priorities.
I remember a conversation I once had with a Vice-President who I was pitching an employer brand campaign focused on proactively raising brand awareness, creating engagement, and building talent pipelines to support her business’s future hiring needs. I shared benchmark data and different talent engagement metrics to highlight the potential return on the investment. I really thought the business case was clear and compelling. Her initial feedback, however, was “I am not convinced”. She then proceeded to explain that the numbers presented were too focused on TA and HR and did not make it clear how the campaign would successfully contribute to addressing her top business priorities, which were not directly linked to talent attraction and retention.
Situations like the above make me think that, perhaps, we, employer brand experts, are missing an opportunity to become more strategic, considering the big picture, beyond what we know well, and truly positioning employer branding as an added value that can enable business success and continuity.
Right at this moment you may be thinking `Okay Ana, I get your point. But how do we strengthen the employer brand business case and evidence its impact on business success if there are multiple variables that we do not control?’ I believe there is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, however, below you can see some of my thoughts to, hopefully, help us get started.
1. Make sure you have a good understanding of the external market trends and how they are likely to impact the business in the short, middle, and long term. Trends such as the advance of technology and the rise of AI, increased focus on sustainability, and the current financial and political instability affecting companies globally, play an important role in defining business strategy and priorities.
2. Get familiar with your business strategy and how it influences the priorities your senior stakeholders have. Leverage these insights when building the employer brand business case. It will help to demonstrate your ability to consider the big picture and bring relevant information to the conversation. As a reward, at the very least, you will assert your position as an employer brand expert and help improve your stakeholders’ understanding of the impact of employer branding on business success.
3. Use relevant data and metrics to support your business case. This is the opportunity to get your stakeholders’ buy-in and investment. Go beyond talent-focused data points and help them visualise the potential impact of the work you are proposing on their goals and priorities. Even if you don’t see a direct connection, try to think outside the box, even if it means making some informed assumptions.
4. Be strategic with your employer brand initiatives, campaigns, and budget. Leverage them, when appropriate, to test new ways to evidence the correlation between employer reputation and business outcomes, and use the insights to bring concrete evidence to future discussions.
Previously, I suggested that we think outside the box to find a correlation, even if not a direct one, between employer brand effectiveness and business outcome. In this section, I want to share some of my thoughts on how we could achieve that.
As it is a general reflection, I will leverage the findings of a survey conducted by Evanta with C-level executives in 2023 to define the most common business priorities, which were found to be:
1. Increasing operational efficiency and productivity
2. Driving growth
3. Optimising or reducing costs
4. Digital business acceleration
5. Improving customer experience
Now it is the time to put our creative hats on and start thinking about different data points and potential connections. Here are some questions I started asking myself.
How much quicker organisations can identify, attract, and hire talent with critical skills when there is an employer brand strategy supporting talent engagement?
Is it possible to create a correlation between the quality of hire and the speed of innovation or digitalisation?
If we remove some variables we can not control from the equation, can we identify a potential link between quality of hire, productivity, and efficiency?
For teams with a clear quantitative performance goal, Sales for example, can we monitor the fluctuation of the average revenue per person before and after an employer brand campaign to hire new sales talent?
Can we determine the cost avoidance (i.e., hiring cost, cost of onboarding and training, cost of rehiring due to attrition) when there is a clear employer brand strategy in place and highlight how the amount could be reallocated to other priority areas (i.e., invest in new technology to drive efficiency)?
Could we run internal pilots to demonstrate how employee engagement can impact productivity (i.e., revenue increase, speed of innovation), improve customer experience (i.e., satisfaction, NPS), and ultimately increase profit?
These are just a few of my initial thoughts to inspire additional reflection and discussion. Depending on the existing metrics and level of maturity of each organisation, accomplishing some of these may be easier or harder, more or less relevant. The key takeaway here is to think about the reality of your organisation and challenge yourself to produce insights and metrics that help leaders to see the value in partnering with the employer brand team, increasing their trust, buy-in, and investment.
Most employer brand experts are used to working with metrics to design and assess the impact of employer brand campaigns and initiatives. We can fluently talk about metrics such as content impressions, engagement rate, apply clicks and so many others related to brand awareness, talent engagement, conversion, and retention. There is no doubt that all these data points are relevant and insightful, however, when connecting with senior executives and other stakeholders in the business who are not as familiar with the employer brand metrics as we are, we must take conscious steps to simplify and translate the message to increase their attention and engagement, especially if the intention is to ask for their support or investment.
By creating a business case that is clear and contains solutions to address critical business priorities, we, employer brand experts, also elevate our reputation as a strategic partner, demonstrating our ability to look beyond the areas we have a direct impact on and present solutions that help drive overall business success. In other words, we increase our value for the organisation.
Looking ahead to the future of employer branding, there is a tremendous opportunity for employer brand experts to step into more strategic roles and become true business partners. That’s a journey some of us are perhaps ahead of others, but in the spirit of advancing our community, I hope this blog provides some food for thought and inspires further discussion.
My career journey in HR began in 2010, and after relocating to the UK, I developed a deep expertise in talent acquisition operations and employer branding. Over the years, I’ve had the privilege of leading and contributing to some incredible employer branding initiatives—from developing a brand-new EVP and crafting its activation strategy across multiple regions to designing and managing both organic and paid campaigns to boost people strategies. Employer branding is more than just my job—it’s my passion. I’m always eager to connect with others in the industry for collaboration and knowledge-sharing.
Connect with Ana on LinkedIn
What to know more about this subject? Listen to our bitesize podcast, we recommend: Evaluating employer brand effectiveness through data with Becky Ralf